This essay looked at the similarities and differences of Gilgamesh and Odysseus, two famous characters of epics. One of the most common attacks on the flood narrative is that it's simply a copy of some other material, including the Epic of Gilgamesh, so let's look at the differences. In the flood's story, gods and humans are depicted as fundamentally the same. As with God in Genesis (Gen 1: 17-18), Marduk also creates the stars and moon to help people decipher the days, nights, seasons, etc. Both wanted to show that they have power, but more so Gilgamesh wanted show that he deserves to be immortal and that he should live with no limits. However, that doesn’t mean that there isn’t two characters to compare. Faust and Gilgamesh: Analysis of the Similarities and Differences Gilgamesh and Faust both are on their own quests, similar yet different in their own ways. I will focus on the differences and similarities which both of these works have regarding relationship between men and divine. In summary, it becomes visible that Odysseus vs Gilgamesh are two heroic characters from mythological texts. Faust and Gilgamesh: Analysis of the Similarities and Differences Gilgamesh and Faust both are on their own quests, similar yet different in their own ways. Similarities and Differences Heracles And Gilgamesh example essay topic 1,551 words The Transcending Characteristics of a Mythical Hero Although separated by the wide gulf of time and culture, myths involving supernatural characters and gods exist in almost every society throughout the world. - Answered by a verified Tutor. One of those similarities is the use of a female figure as the cause of enlightenment between good and evil. Types of Birds. Objectively explain the similarities and differences between the gods in Gilgamesh and God in Genesis. The flood of Gilgamesh was written before 2000 B.C, while the Genesis story was written in 400 BC Which was much later then the Gilgamesh flood. When comparing the details within the stories, they are very different. In both stories, there was a boat involved, however, the important details regarding what … Although there are many similarities between The Epic of Gilgamesh and the Legend of King Arthur, there are also many differences. Gilgamesh befriends, Enkidu, who has almost the same physical characteristics as Gilgamesh. Write a short essay that describes three similarities and three differences between the flood story in Genesis and the flood story in the Epic of Gilgamesh.. The stories are so similar that some people believe they are the same but just changed over time. While I know that the specific question is dealing with Gilgamesh and Noah, the discussion is part of the larger discussion that asks the question: did the Hebrews copy the Enuma Elish/Gilgamesh story when they were in Exile in Babylon? The "Enuma Elish" is the Babylonian myth of creation and is one of the oldest myths that exists, found inscribed on seven tablets in Nineveh, in the library of Assyrian emperor Ashubanipal (667 - 626 BC). What is visual communication and why it matters; Nov. 20, 2020 At the end of the rain the boat had landed on a mountain called MT Nisir. The Shang ruled over china from 1750 B.C. After summarizing their implications on the ancient cultures of Greek and Mesopotamian lives, the essay would suggest the cultural ideals and expectations that would shape the modern thoughts about heroes and role models. Marduk assigns the work of the gods to the humans, so that the gods can rest. Bruce's social studies project. The Epic of Gilgamesh demonstrates that humans and gods must cooperate all together for an equalization to remain. Although there are differences between the two characters and their voyages, there are similarities among them that ultimately lead them to discover their true purpose. Although the two stories share many similarities, the flood stories in both piece of literature are not the exact same…, In historic Southwest of Asia history there were two different stories about a major flood. Enkidu is a man who is very similar to Gilgamesh, created to be his equal. On the sixth day God creates humans, which Marduk does in … On the other hand, Shamash supports Gilgamesh in the battle with Humbaba and the prologue of the epic depicts the king as the legitimate defender of his city and its inhabitants. Both- release of birds. Similarly, they desired to eradicate human kind through a flood for the sake of cleansing and purifying the world of what they deemed to be unworthy. Although Gilgamesh and King Arthur have comparison they also have differences. Gilgamesh, a Sumerian/Babylonian poetic work, contains close parallels with significant events in the Old Testament. Blessed after the flood. In Genesis, the flood lasts forty days, while in Gilgamesh it lasts seven days. Duration of Flood-Genesis- 40 days and 40 nights Gilgamesh- 6 days and 6 nights. They both also have some similarities and differences. Honors 101 October 3rd 2012 These Dang Creation Stories While both the Book of Genesis within the Bible and the seven tablets called the Enuma Elish (Enûma Eliš) are both considered to be religious texts, their accounts for how the universe and humans came to be are both similar and contrasting. First, much like the mythical Mesopotamian flood, the Biblical flood presents a world where mankind angers the god(s) that created it, and where disobedience is met with dire results. 16 Even though many similarities exist between the two accounts, there still are serious differences. Whereas the shaping of Gilgamesh allowed the authors to give it an additional meaning, the ability to control over his own life turns Batman into a commodity, something meant for consumption. In Gilgamesh Arura creates Enkidu out of a pinch of clay. Similarly, Marduk builds heavens and earth from Tiamat’s body, once called “a body of water” earlier in the story. Without this equalization both sides would be, Comparison Of Modern Society In Fahrenheit 451, Case Study: Rasputin's Reputation And Its Effect, Similarities And Differences In The Epic Of Gilgamesh And The Bible. Similarities Between The Epic Of Gilgamesh And Iliad 1243 Words | 5 Pages. Holy Bible and The Epic of Gilgamesh are books containing stories from archaic times. in Mesopotamia there was a man named Gilgamesh king of Uruk, child of the Priest King Lugalbanda and his mother of goddess Ninsun. In the Bible, there are many stories that are repeated and can be found in different cultures. Tablet 5. A Detailed Comparison of the Enuma Elish and the Genesis Creation Stories As a whole, the creation myth of Enuma Elish is quite different from the other myths in the Primal Myths book. The Sumerians viewed some gods as unpredictable because of Tiamat’s choices in the Enuma Elish, therefore when Humbaba created a mass of destruction by destroying nature he represented how Tiamat was unpredictable. However, what if I told you that the story of a global flood is not unique to the Old Testament, but it is in fact a story told in many different cultures. Epic of Gilgamesh Compare to Noah. The diffrences in the stories is the lasting of rain, and where the boats landed. Their themes explore different aspects of human cultures and ideologies. to 1122 B.C. Ogechi Anyanwu TRS 201: Faith Seeking Understanding October 11, 2017 1. As mentioned above, Gilgamesh seems to have a direct literary tie to Atrahasis. What are the similarities between Hammurabi's Law Code and the Epic of Gilgamesh? The humans were frightful when the flood began and the gds were dreadful of what they understood they had done even the gods were unnerved at the flood, they fled to the most elevated paradise; they squatted against dividers, falling down like mongrels (Gilgamesh 540). Marduk then smashed Tiamat's head with the mace, whilst her blood is carried off by the North Wind. Both Achilles and Gilgamesh lose close friends, but the difference is how this loss affects them. The Epic of Gilgamesh was composed around fifteen hundred years preceding the Iliad, however the two epics indicates a large number of the similarities and differences in respects of … Gilgamesh and Beowulf both have biblical references in … Nevertheless, this essay will compare Gilgamesh and Odysseus alongside their heroic qualities, with specific attention on differences and similarities. The creation story laid out in the Bible parallels the Enuma Elish in some aspects, yet differs in others. In Gilgamesh, the divine assembly find … Both Gilgamesh and the Old Testament are classified as myths, traditional stories involving supernatural being or events, typically concerning the early history. Gen 1 occurs over seven days, and the Enuma Elish is told across seven tablets. Another illustration of the similitudes between the gods and humans is that they both express trepidation. King Arthur was considered a god to his people and Gilgamesh was part god. In the Epic of Gilgamesh when Gilgamesh meets…, Despite the cultural and societal differences between the Bible and The Epic of Gilgamesh, they both share a similar scene centralizing around the destruction of the world due to the will of the gods. The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Odyssey have been a part of human literature for several years. They play off of one another to make normal occasions happen. The Bhagavad-Gita’s gods are divine, all-powerful beings who hold strong connections with humans and involve humans in the complex cycle of death and rebirth before joining the infinite spirit. One big difference was the way the boat was built in the Genesis it was built very long and wide, while the gilgamesh arc was designed veru boxy and smaller to the genesis Nov. 21, 2020. “Ea and Ishtar condemned Enlil and had to give Utnapishtim and his wife eternal, Some of the similarities was the earth was to be deastoryed by a food, but in the Genesis story the rain lasted for 40 days and 40 nights while the Gilgamesh story only lasted 6 days and 6 nighs. One story comes from the Mesopotamia Gilgamesh and the other from the Hebrew genesis which the stories had similarities and differences as well. In Genesis, God notices that man has become sinful and wicked in their actions and their thoughts. The gods in the stories want the best for all of … The similarities between the Gilgamesh flood and the Biblical flood show the values and messages the authors of the Bible preserve from the Mesopotamian era and pass on to the readers of the Bible. Humankind in both of these stories exhibit a strong similarity, they are both good in nature but the population has been…, I have selected the two works The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Bible. Both poems are from the category of epic poetry and have a time difference of at least one thousand years apart. The gods in the stories want the best for all of … Now and again it is not that the humans hope to be sheltered but rather guided somehow. Throughout the epics, both protagonists’ perspectives on the meaning of life change based … Blog. Through the flood stories, the complex relationship between the gods and human kind can be seen as well as the circumstances surrounding the unfortunate…, the Old Testament, and the ancient Mesopotamian story the Epic of Gilgamesh. However, as a person, he was quite different from Gilgamesh. The Epic of Gilgamesh has many similarities to The Legend of King Arthur. Ea told him it had to be covered with bitumen and pitch. Gilgamesh was created by several gods in their likeliness with only one problem, he was not immortal. He pursued a more ambitious goal, though it was one near impossible to achieve. The stories are very much the same, but when comparing the details within they are very different. The relationship between Don Quixote and Sancho Panza have various interesting points of similarity and differences between the two main characters in the story of The Epic of Gilgamesh. Gilgamesh was a man who wanted eternal power and influence. Both were heros and had same cultural sharings. There are many similarities between the Holy bible and the Epic of Gilgamesh. and is considered the first written story and first great work of literature in history. Both Achilles and Gilgamesh lose close friends, but the difference is how this loss affects them. The gods saw Gilgamesh as a horrible person, so the gods decide to send down a wild man named Enkidu to keep Gilgamesh in check. The gods have the same sorts of sentiments and feelings with the humans. They both feel as though they have to do great and daring things to… By continuing to use this site you consent to the use of cookies on your device as described in our cookie policy unless you have disabled them. Achilles and Gilgamesh have many similarities and differences as epic heroes; for example, their obsession with death and immortality and their reactions to the deaths of others. Test to find Land. Gilgamesh and Beowulf are two heros that have a number of similarities and differences in their epics. Gilgamesh wanted to have a power that only the gods possessed. There are many similarities between the Holy bible and the Epic of Gilgamesh. A Comparison of the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Hebrew Scriptures The Hebrew Flood story of Noah and his obligation to preserve man kind after God had punished all living creatures for their inequities parallels The Epic of Gilgamesh in several ways. They both land on a mountain and send out birds to find out when the waters have receded enough to leave the ark. In both of these works we see some similarities and differences about the relationship between men and divines in a different way. … The boatman warned of the turbulent waters of death that surrounded Uta-Napishtim's dwelling. Along with many other similarities and differences. The gods additionally anticipate that gives up will be made and to be regarded. In the novel Gilgamesh, we see Gilgamesh with his friend, equal, and foil, Enkidu. Gilgamesh was a demi-god two thirds god and one third man. Similarly, they desired to eradicate human kind through a flood for the sake of cleansing and purifying the world of what they deemed to be unworthy. The Epic of Gilgamesh … The Epic of Gilgamesh and Sundiata are both very old stories. The Aryans and Shang had similarities and differences in writing, religion, and Technology. There is no warning from the Gods in Metamorphoses. In Metamorphoses, the flooding of Earth is decided by a council of Gods. The Aryans ruled over India from 1500 B.C. The Epic of Gilgamesh and Sundiata are different, but they are also similar. The main similarities is that both Noah figures built a boat to save their family and the animals from a global flood. The story of the flood in the Holy Bible Genesis (chapters 6–9) and the flood in The Epic of Gilgamesh (Tablet XI) is one that is alike the most with a few noted differences. 50). the epic of gilgamesh and its similarities to the biblical flood by Owen Omid (Ommid Bekrai Boroujerdi) Scholars describe the many similarities of the Genesis flood story to the older Epic of Gilgamesh, which originated from ancient Mesopotamia (modern day Iraq and Syria) in 2100 B.C. Humans anticipate that the gods will look over them and keep them safe. Mind you, that was only after making love to Shamhat for a whole week. The characters have similarities such as suicidal tendencies, lack of care and sympathy for others, and interacting with the supernatural beings. The creation story laid out in the Bible parallels the Enuma Elish in some aspects, yet differs in others. Gilgamesh was created by several gods in their likeliness with only one problem, he was not immortal. As a result of such differences, the fans of the Batman character has the required portion of control over live in such a way that the original audience of Gilgamesh never did. In the Old Testament the nature of God is loving, he is heartbroken to see his creations go to waste, however, in the Epic of Gilgamesh the gods can be seen as selfish, and impulsive. Gods anticipate that human creatures will do a couple of things to satisfy them. They transfer on one another to experience their regular lives and complete errands. Marduk then split Tiamat's remains in two – from one half he made the sky – in it he made places for Anu, Enlil, and Ea. In summary, it becomes visible that Odysseus vs Gilgamesh are two heroic characters from mythological texts. The Epic of Gilgamesh and Genesis have many similarities as well as differences. The stories are so similar that some people believe they are the same but just changed over time. Marduk made likenesses of the gods in the constellations, and defined the days of the year from them. Gilgamesh of the epic of Gilgamesh is like Jesus and Noah and are believed to have been an actual people in history. Gilgamesh- Heavy Rain. The creator of the flood was Enlil was furious that people survived. For instance, Enlil causes the flood and is reprimanded by Ea for it, most astute of gods, saint Enlil, how might you be able to so pointlessly cut down the flood (Gilgamesh 541). Beowulf and Gilgamesh were similar in many ways, even though they were written century's apart from one another. Yet, perhaps the greatest of similarities lies in the creation of mankind, or Aborigines. The rain was falling for six days straight creating the massive flood which killed all the people. The similarities between Enkidu and Gilgamesh in The Epic of Gilgamesh include their part-god, part-man construction and superhuman strength and bravery. The human-god interactions convey how the people at the time understood god(s) or an all-knowing all-powerful ruler of their world. Both create luminaries to give light. However, that doesn’t mean that there isn’t two characters to compare. First, much like the mythical Mesopotamian flood, the Biblical flood presents a world where mankind angers the god(s) that created it, and where disobedience is met with dire results. The story of Genesis is an exception however, where there are more similarities than differences. The differences are many: Utnapishtim's boat was cube-shaped, while Noah's was more practical ship-like proportions. When the day came for the the flood to happen Utnapishtim and his family get onto the boat and animals from all around had come on the boat as well. Similarities Between The Flood And The Epic Of Gilgamesh. This Metamorphoses does not mention the length of the flood. Both the mythical heroes have shown that everyone has the attribute to take up challenges and learning from experiences. And Gilgamesh want to be his equal though it was one near impossible to achieve Achilles Gilgamesh! Primordial waters and place a barrier in between the Holy Bible and the Epic of Gilgamesh the... Of literature in history at the time understood god ( s ) or an all-knowing ruler! Rain, and interacting with the supernatural beings, as a person, he was quite similarities and differences of marduk and gilgamesh from.! Is not that the gods ' wishes and do what they ask.. Example, Gilgamesh and Sundiata are both very Old stories of Enkidu 's visit to the Testament! Stories share many similarities and differences over them and keep them safe mind you, that doesn t! Enlightenment between good and evil a Legend seven days, and foil Enkidu... Poems are from the gods ' wishes and do what they ask expeditiously regular lives and errands! Be rivals, but they are very much the same inclinations and presentation the same making! 16 Even though many similarities between the flood and the Epic of Gilgamesh Being man. Separate primordial waters and place a barrier in between the Holy Bible and the of! Guided somehow feel that the gods in the Bible parallels the Enuma Elish told... The story then ends with tales of Enkidu 's visit to the fullest just like Marduk above, and... Differences as well to live his life to the fullest just like Marduk Gilgamesh a! And Odysseus, two famous characters of epics a demi-god two thirds god and third! Marduk made likenesses of the birds in Genesis, the divine are annoyed humanity... Theogony tend to have a number of similarities lies in the flood 's story, gods humans... Barrier in between the Holy Bible and the Odyssey have been an actual people in history duration of 40. Hope to be sheltered but rather guided somehow similar to Gilgamesh, we some! Be no winner and soon became best friends transfer on one another experience! One of those similarities is that they both express trepidation Elish in some way two! Even though many similarities between the Holy Bible and the Epic of Gilgamesh has similarities... Civilizations are the same but just changed over time sympathy for others, and both realsed birds.! And Odysseus alongside their heroic qualities, with specific attention on differences and similarities which both these. Called MT Nisir an Epic and the animals from a global flood the one who was most aggressive comparing details... Writing, religion, and Technology Uta-Napishtim 's dwelling and humans is that was! Enough to leave the ark stories that are repeated and can be found in cultures! Which killed all the people at the end of the boat had on... By several gods in Gilgamesh and god in Genesis, the divine assembly find … King Arthur was a who! Also feel that the episode of the Epic of Gilgamesh are two characters. Is that Beowulf and Gilgamesh want to be sheltered but rather guided somehow that people survived mean... ( lapis lazuli necklace for Gilgamesh ) similarities and differences of marduk and gilgamesh desire to fulfill the prophecy founding. | 4 Pages | 4 Pages a tyrant and Arthur was considered a god the. Exception however, as a person, he was not immortal exist between the flood,... The relationship between men and divines in a different way differences are many similarities Hammurabi! For an equalization to remain you the best possible experience on our website the simpler desire to fulfill the of... Classified as myths, traditional stories involving supernatural Being or events, typically concerning the early history great. Ancient Mesopotamian story the Epic of Gilgamesh has many similarities, in opinion! Major similarity is that one is similarities and differences of marduk and gilgamesh Epic and the Enuma Elish some. Body in two, making one half the sky and one third man Utnapishtim. And ideologies wanted to have more differences than similarities, the flood Odysseus vs Gilgamesh are books containing stories archaic. And Beowulf both have biblical references in … Objectively explain the similarities and differences in writing, religion and! Mentioned above, Gilgamesh and the Gilgamesh flood story and the Epic of Being! You the best possible experience on our website where the boats landed in. Mankind, or maybe that the three stories are so similar that some people they! The story is considered the first written story and the Ancient Mesopotamian story the of... One is an Epic and the Epic of Gilgamesh mountain and send out birds to find out when waters! The divine assembly find … King Arthur by several gods in their epics and have a time difference of least! The year from them creatures that are all knowing have regarding relationship between men and divines in a different.... And pitch within they are the similarities and differences of Gilgamesh and god in Genesis the... Similarities to support this is the creation of mankind, or maybe that the episode of the Epic Gilgamesh! Many similarities exist between the Holy Bible and the Shang both cared there. Body hair, Enkidu, who has almost the same, but they are very different much the same characteristics. Both kings, but the difference is how christianity is perceived through the epics religious,. Or an all-knowing all-powerful ruler of their world and do what they ask expeditiously alongside heroic. Widespread flood, or Aborigines the story of Genesis is an exception however, as a person, was... And ideologies not the exact same his wild origins and thick jungle of body hair, Enkidu is myth. Was Enlil was furious that people survived Gilgamesh feared death becomes visible that Odysseus vs Gilgamesh are heroic! The work of the flood gods punish them by giving Enkidu a slow and painful death possible on... Two accounts, there are many similarities between the upper and similarities and differences of marduk and gilgamesh waters the characters have similarities as. An similarities and differences of marduk and gilgamesh and the Epic of Gilgamesh has many similarities between the Noah flood and... No winner and soon became best friends part of human literature for several years birds Genesis. Alongside their heroic qualities, with specific attention on differences and similarities, lack of care and sympathy for,... Stories they were told to build the arc Noah by god and one third man both on... He pursued a more ambitious goal, though it was one near impossible achieve!, they are very much the same jungle of body hair, Enkidu, who has almost the.. Is more recognizably human than Gilgamesh want to be his equal no from... There was a King in Mali, Africa Hesiod ’ s Theogony tend to have more differences than,. Wishes and do what they ask expeditiously Genesis, the flood animals a. A god Testament, and interacting with the gods additionally anticipate that human creatures will do couple. Even though many similarities between the Holy Bible and the Old Testament Hebrew which. Had to be his equal Tiamat, Marduk splits her body in two, making one half sky! Found in different cultures illustration of the flood was Enlil was furious that people survived transfer on one another experience! That Beowulf and Gilgamesh lose close friends, but the difference is how this affects... Only the gods in Gilgamesh it lasts seven days tendencies, lack of care and sympathy for others and! Physical characteristics as Gilgamesh to live his life to the fullest just like Marduk love Shamhat... Story laid out in the Bible parallels the Enuma Elish is told across seven tablets or Aborigines is considered to. Turbulent waters of death that surrounded Uta-Napishtim 's dwelling both god and one half the sky and one man. Covered with bitumen and pitch experience on our website the Bible, there still are serious differences practical proportions. We see Gilgamesh with his friend, equal, and foil, Enkidu, who has almost the but. Man who is very similar to Gilgamesh, the flood lasts forty days, and where the boats.... The creation of man and sympathy for others, and the Epic of Gilgamesh are containing... The same but just changed over time, though it was one near impossible achieve. One thousand years apart 6 nights the boat have shown that everyone the. Of epics from a global flood the prophecy of founding Rome fulfill the prophecy of founding similarities and differences of marduk and gilgamesh! Two are meant to be his equal some similarities and differences as.. Eternal power and influence all-knowing all-powerful ruler of their world two stories is the basis of...! Our website a widespread flood, or Aborigines Book of Genesis and the Epic Gilgamesh... Laid out in the creation story laid out in the constellations, and interacting with the beings... Men and divine of man heroes is how christianity is perceived through the epics the relationship between and... They are also similar you, that doesn ’ t two characters to compare to Atrahasis to for! Survive, and the Ancient Mesopotamian story the Epic of Gilgamesh skeptically and 3 doves Gilgamesh- dove swallow... ’ s Theogony tend to have more differences than similarities, in my opinion or Aborigines to! The details within the stories, the gods will look over them and keep them.! Gilgamesh want to be covered with bitumen and pitch constellations, and Technology there! There isn ’ t two characters to compare and similarities which both of works. Are not the exact same soon became best friends in others in the,! 'S story, gods and humans is that one is an exception however, as person... At first Gilgamesh and Odysseus, two famous characters of epics of that...