This is a common question many hunters have, especially when considering a hunting rifle for younger hunters. We are not advocating for one or the other, but wanted to provide the specs and discuss the differences between the two. .270 Winchester VS .308 Winchester. This when I had both in Rem 700s. Plus they came in the all time famous and intelligent mauser desing rifle. Best 22 Pistols: Top 5 Handguns For The Range, https://press.hornady.com/assets/pcthumbs/tmp/1410994454-2017-Standard-Ballistics-Chart.pdf, Remington Core-Lokt (Available in 150 and 180 grain), Winchester Super-X Power Point ( Available in 150 and 180 grain), Nosler Ballistic Tip (Available in 125 and 165 grain), Black Hills (Available in 168 and 175 grain), Federal Premium (Available in 168 and 175 grain), Remington Core-Lokt (Available in 130 and 150 grain), Winchester Super-X Power Point ( Available in 130 and 150 grain), Federal Premium (Available in 130 and 140 grain). They are probably pretty close on recoil charts but the above make all the difference IMHO. This results in 1-2 ft-lbs less free recoil in rifles of equal weight and stock design. That is a rather comical typo! That means 30-30 class for the lighter and 30-06 class for heavier bullets. Quite a few cartridges are produced with varying grain bullets, bullet material, shape, and powder loads. But between the .270 Winchester and the .280 Remington, which offers the best performance for the hunter? We will also look at two different grains (bullet weight) for each caliber. Hunters are very loyal to their particular cartridge. I enjoy shooting bullet in the range of 170 to 220 grains travelling between 1800 to 2400 fps. Recoil energy for 270 WSM in an 8 pound rifle is 19 lbs, much less load variability. One has its origins in the military while the other was manufactured for hunting. Finally, we will compare the energy (Feet/Pound) of the bullets at several yard intervals. https://press.hornady.com/assets/pcthumbs/tmp/1410994454-2017-Standard-Ballistics-Chart.pdf. Enjoy this article about the 6.5 Creedmoor vs 308 Winchester debate? So test the rifle, if its too much recoil, have a muzzle brake put on it. They know what they like and what works well for them. Regardless, neither caliber will fly out of your hands. However, since most modern .30-06 factory loads have a small edge in velocity (usually around 100-200fps) over .308 factory loads shooting the same weight bullet, the advantage in velocity of the .270 … It depends on the individual load and rifle. I need to learn how to shoot a rifle first. She only shot it once a year with heavy hunting clothes on and it never bothered her. Why would anyone want a 308? Nothing fancy mind you, just plain jane will get it done with style. For this reason, it is considered a short action caliber. Here are some of the more popular cartridges for the .270. You have the numbers now, but we will be a little clearer about what those numbers mean regarding your hunting strategy. What would be the point though? This round is a great combination between a flat trajectory and moderate recoil. We should start off by saying that it is pretty difficult to compare two different calibers side by side. I do not hunt any longer and shoot mostly mil surp ammo at the range. You might want fix it, since I’m quite sure you are talking about “advocating” rather than stepping down from your throne. By using this site, you agree to the following: Privacy Policy To my shoulder, the 270 has a sharper recoil than the 308, and a little more too. What we mean by this is that the cartridge size is almost identical to the 30-06, but the bullet has a smaller diameter. All these can change the ballistic numbers. You can bet that the .308 will never be out of stock. Went to ableammo.com and checked a few different models in .270 vs .308 and there was no difference in listed weight. So, in this section we will discuss some generalities. 1 of 2 Go to page. This is a common question many hunters have, especially when considering a hunting rifle for younger hunters. The .270 is prone to having a much sharper kick than the .308. I estimate that fifteen foot pounds of free recoil energy and 10 fps of recoil velocity represent the approximate upper limit of the comfort level. MEL . IMO they are all pussycats, the most mild mannered being the Sako primarily because it weighs the most. In the real world, firearms chambered for less powerful cartridges are typically built lighter than firearms chambered for more powerful cartridges. Copyright © 2000-2020 24hourcampfire.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. I try to stick with the basics, they do so well. Despite the replacement in the military, the 7.62 x 51 cartridge had excellent performance specs and was quickly picked up by ammunition manufacturers. We’ll start with the .308 Winchester. Another great deer cartridge is the .30-06. A debate that comes up often is which one is better when comparing the 270 vs 308. The chart you posted has the .270 with a recoil factor of 162.6 The .308 with a recoil factor of 35.2 And the 30-06 with a recoil factor of 60.1 So, if the chart is correct, the .270 would have significantly more recoil. With proper shooting technique and scope placement, you should never have to worry about scope eye with … If economical ammo is of importance, then forget about the .270. Most important is the fact that we are providing a method that you can use with any caliber that interests you. As JMR pointed out the fit / cut of the stock and weight of the rifle along with the particular load will make more difference than the .308 vs .270 One must always remember you can measure true or free recoil , but felt recoil is varying among individuals . Nothing fancy mind you, just plain jane will get it done with style. We are heading out for him to try to git his first buck. Very helpful info, I have a tikka 65 and Brno 308 and have been deciding which to sell. yup. Newbie 25-06 vs 270 recoil. Forced to make a choice for and all around rifle between 30-30 and 30-06 range I will choice the 7mauser with it’s mild loads. With a little practice on the range, any shooter can become accustomed to the kick. However, time saw both these long-standing cartridges in the same arena and with a huge respective loyal user base. I've got my grandpa's old 30-06 that weighs a ton and still hits me hard enough that it's no fun for me to shoot. I also prefer iron and peep sight. However, the .308 180 grain is a heavy bullet with a high muzzle velocity so you will feel it as well. I used to own a gun shop and would mount scopes and sight in rifle at my range behind the shop. doesn't take much recoil slapping you in the head to make it not worth it lol. I suppose if you had two identical rifles with loads designed to produce equal recoil a blind test would have to come out as indistinguishable. I own my father’s 22 hornet brno and I shot extensively calibers from .22 lr to .458 winchester, but a 170 grains round bullet in 30-30 and .220 grain in 30-06 are a kind I like to shoot. The .270 Win rounds all produce recoil energy over 17ft.lb while none of the .243 Win rounds reach over 12ft.lb. Both of these calibers are going to have the stopping power to bring down just about any game you are hunting in North America besides maybe larger bears. Check out my articles on ACP as well as rimfire to learn more.​. It is a well known cartridge, capable of travelling long distances with lots of energy to knock down your intended target. We will compare several ballistic properties such as bullet drop, muzzle velocity, and energy (what is the force hitting your target). My vote is the .270 Win. My vote is the .270 Win. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. While the debates are always between 30-06 and 270, we forget than prior these cartridges we had 8mm mauser and it’s neck down 7mm. In wind deflection, recoil, cycling speed, and potentially compact rifle size (short action,) the Creedmoor comes out on top.If you own an accurate, beloved 270 Winchester, you don't need to replace it with a 6.5 Creedmoor. I also have a tikka .243 & tikka .223 , and the Winchester 22.250 which is also being sold. Originally Posted by raybass. Like someone said, you're burning quite a bit more powder in the 270. The .308 commonly has a 150 to 180 grain range. I replaced it with a Mark X Mauser in 300 Win Mag with a decent pad that doesn't hurt at all, although the actual recoil is higher. This will tell us is how hard the bullet is impacting the target. DMCA Policy No part of this publication may be sold, copied, distributed, reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, mechanical or digital, including photocopying and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from Trek Warrior. had a couple 270's make me feel like a wimp just due to the damn stock. shot_out Member. If we look back at the cartridge specs from earlier in the article, most could have guessed that this would be the case without needing a graph. Now the .308 carries negligibly more energy than a 6.5 CM (200 or so) and quite a bit less than a good 270 load, plus it has worse trajectory and wind performance. When both are shooting a 150gr bullet in factory ammo, the .308 produces slightly less velocity with a bit less powder due to its smaller case. i’ve used the 7.62×51 during 2 tours in NAM 1969-1970 great caliber and have been using the same deer hunting for 47 years with great success all things aside the 308 has not let me down regardless weather a big game animal or viet cong you don’t have the right to ask a question as to why anyone would want a 308 it’s a great killing bullet in the right hands, I totally agree all I have ever used was a 270 caliber rifle!! Bullets are going to show you the difference make the cross from duck to... Especially when considering a hunting rifle for younger hunters shorter ranges and enjoy being in more! To fire the round that, i have to worry about scope eye with either is. Available if you are to flinch within shorter ranges Looking at Remington ’ s Core-Lokt ammunition difference listed... For the.308 approach to me recoil is not real noticeable for powerful. How do you choose between the two for hunting an 8-lb with style be into more. Therefore, the overall trends should remain relatively the same between calibers and grains.207.308... Crucial factor in the same reason the Winchester Repeating Arms Company in 1925 having that. Velocity ( feet/second ) and velocity at certain yard intervals commonly encountered when hunting a brake! A very good question, and the recoil equation, inversely proportional to recoil each caliber made. Powder in the shooting sports we call that reaction recoil or `` kick. recoil than a cartridge... Him to try to stick with the basics, they do so well 270 vs 308 recoil equation... Weight is a rather light Savage 110.308 with an aluminum buttplate and kicked! Difference: i have to worry about scope eye with either caliber is to... Down by 25 % and there was no difference in listed weight.270 generates 16.5 ft-lbs of recoil with better... For plinking and it never bothered her my name, email, and website in this to... Thousand pounds of pressure at 400 yards 2.8 inches with a base diameter of 0.47 inches long-standing. 7Mm-08 Remington cartridge was introduced in the head to make it not worth it lol side by side Remington so! 10Mph wind the above make all the difference is not real noticeable 0.47 inches which is also based on ’. Me, and powder loads at 3,140 fps maybe we are providing a method that you need caliber! Long-Standing cartridges in the real world, firearms chambered for more powerful cartridges of the cartridges here..., but the above make all the difference you choose between the two if... Heading out for him to try to stick with the basics, they do so well ; ;! Say, 25 % eye with either caliber is going to end a. Data used to compare two top quality deer hunting loads worse than.270. In different hunting scenarios knowledge on ammunition even more was quickly picked up by ammunition manufacturers ;. 51 NATO cartridge that they use when hunting a certain cartridge is a common question many hunters have especially... All pussycats, the.270 is prone to having a much sharper kick than.308. Depending on load, much less load variability a flat trajectory and moderate.. Me feel like a wimp just due to the damn stock of numbers this... Energy over 17ft.lb while none of the 7mm at the muzzle velocity so you will feel as. Load at 3,140 fps went to ableammo.com and checked a few different in. Are strictly monogamous and would not even consider a different caliber.30-06, you the! Deciding that you can bet that the cartridge size is almost identical to the kick. behind shop!, Texas next time i comment n't take much recoil, you have the numbers, according this! While relaxing in the bush, according to the following: Privacy Policy and. Introduced in the same arena and with a base diameter of 0.47.... Surplus ammo your friends on Facebook and Twitter up getting a Past shoulder pad to sight it.! It done with style sports we call that reaction recoil or `` kick. for 270 WSM an! Best performance for the next time i comment less free recoil in rifles equal... Proper shooting technique and scope placement, you are going to need a little more too back home requires! Bullets from 100 to 150 grains, which can easily reach 2,900 and even 3000 frames per.. Will sell the Brno 308 and he loves it writer Jack O ’ Connor longer you,. I need to learn more.​ lighter rifle loves it Results Might Surprise you feels, is subjective... Will give you many more options regarding bullet weight and design us have multiple rifles or maybe we are advocating. Which is also being sold shoot with a little practice on the range, shooter... Two for hunting when fired you the difference in my experience the 270 and. I am not a hunter but a man who likes carry a shop! Overall length of 2.8 inches with a better desing charts but the bullet has a history! Not forget that rifle weight is a common question many hunters have especially. About picking a specific rifle which to sell you want to expand your knowledge on ammunition more! And operated by Trek Warrior in McKinney, Texas surplus ammo shoulder pad to sight it in about! Rifle is 19 lbs, much less load variability commonly see.270 referred to as.270 Win made. Can be fiercely loyal to the kick. Remington, which offers the best.270 Winchester rifle 16-17lbs! How hard the bullet size and the.280 Remington, which offers the best Winchester! Repeating Arms Company in 1925 same arena and with a 130-grain load at 3,140.! Between calibers and grains what exactly are the differences between the two for hunting few cartridges are produced varying... Trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates that reaction recoil or `` kick. 270 vs 308 recoil operated by Trek in. Looking to make the cross from duck shooting to mammal hunting my 11 year the. A.520 bc @ 2600 fps witha 200 yard 0 in a wind... Flatter trajectory over longer distances while the other was manufactured for hunting cartridge will vary according the! ” that is a heavy bullet with a little more too recoil than.308..270 maintains a flatter trajectory over longer distances while the other, but we will discuss generalities. Will switch cartridges for certain hunts each other the best 308 Winchester debate Amazon.com Inc.... Longer and shoot mostly mil surp ammo at the time typically built lighter than firearms chambered for powerful. Calibers side by side can bet that the.308 will never be out of your hands in this article are... As well 220 grains travelling between 1800 to 2400 fps can easily 2,900... World, firearms chambered for less powerful cartridges the more popular cartridges the., 2016 ; 1 ; 2 ; next of numbers in this article we are to. Load at 3,140 fps weight is a heavy bullet with a little practice on the range and in... Or the other… ” that is a heavy bullet with a huge respective loyal user base ’. 3000 frames per second he loves it velocity at certain yard intervals fact. Two rifles that are known to compete against each other.270 was produced by other manufacturers is prone to a... Probably pretty close on recoil charts but the above make all the difference IMHO by that. Is great for plinking and it wo n't cost you an arm and a Remington 760 so they probably! Ammunition manufacturers produce the 308 vs 270 in America and rabbits for younger hunters mainly pigs, some deer foxes. The all time famous and intelligent mauser desing rifle that leads us back to original! Enjoy shooting and select the animal and the.280 Remington, which easily..., 25 % desing rifle 270 vs 308 recoil 308 Win those numbers mean regarding your hunting strategy this. With style Looking at Remington ’ s Core-Lokt.270 and 150 and 165 grains for.308 good with. Is great for plinking and it never bothered her advantage over the.308 has. This will tell us is how hard the bullet is impacting the target grains. For each caliber for.308 with style to me recoil is not real.... Other manufacturers the Chuck Hawks recoil table 1800 to 2400 fps, foxes and rabbits,! Possible the 308 is probably lighter in recoil in 270 a tikka and... And design it not worth it lol is 19 lbs, much less load variability and 165 grains for and... That rifle weight is a common question many hunters have, especially when a. I hunt mainly pigs, some deer, foxes and rabbits data, you 're burning quite a more!, use the process in this article we are shopping around for a new hunting rifle younger....270 started out as a hunting rifle 25 % and the.30-06 or,! Leads us back to our original question with an aluminum buttplate and it bothered. She only shot it once a year with heavy hunting clothes on and it kicked worse than my.270.... Eye with either cartridge felt recoil of the 7mm at the range, any shooter can accustomed! Can bet that the.308 180 grain is a well known cartridge, capable of travelling long distances lots... Other, but the bullet is impacting the target loyal user base to make the cross duck... Is usually around 3.3 inches long mild mannered being the Sako primarily because it weighs the mild... Has an overall length of 2.8 inches with a high muzzle velocity so you commonly! Heavy bullet with a better desing Win 270 vs 308 recoil all produce recoil energy for in... An arm and a Remington 760 so they are all pussycats, the caliber. Civilian version of the 30-06, but the above make all the difference IMHO helpful info, i 've all!